03-decemberdbstudyguide2011


03-decemberdbstudyguide2011

1 Pages 1-10

▲back to top

1.1 Page 1

▲back to top
DECEMBER 2011
Getting to Know
Don Bosco
The Memoirs
Thanks goes out to Fr. Tim
Ploch, the Provincial of the
Western Province for providing
each Professed Salesian with a
personal copy of the Memoirs of
the Oratory of Saint Francis de
Sales as recently re-printed and
made available at Salesiana
Publishers. For those members of
the Salesian Family receiving this
guide, you are encouraged to
purchase a personal copy.
Personal copies are priced at $12.00
and can be ordered at:
Salesiana Publishers
c/o SRM Distribution Services
75 West Century Road, Suite 200
Paramus, NJ 07652
phone 201-986-0503
fax 201-986-0504
e-mail: srmdist@verizon.net
His Place in History
Come Share Reflections and
Insights!
This January there are two events offering further study and
reflection on Don Bosco’s life and his place in history. In both
Southern California & Northern California there will be three
evenings of study. For those wishing a more reflective
experience, a Friday evening through Sunday lunch style retreat
will also be offered.
January 2012 Study Evenings and Retreats
Evening One
Monday January 9
Don Bosco Hall,
Berkeley 7-9PM
Evening Two
Tuesday January 10
Don Bosco Hall,
Berkeley 7-9PM
Evening Three
Wednesday January 11
Don Bosco Hall,
Berkeley 7-9PM
Evening One
Tuesday January 17
St. Joseph’s Youth
Renewal Center,
Rosemead 7-9PM
Evening Two
Wed. January 18
St. Joseph’s Youth
Renewal Center,
Rosemead 7-9PM
Evening Three
Thursday January 19
St. Joseph’s Youth
Renewal Center,
Rosemead 7-9PM
Detailed flyers and registration information are found
in the last pages of this study guide.

1.2 Page 2

▲back to top
12
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
The Comollo Biography
Comollo’s Biography was reworked many times
for different audiences
Don Bosco’s Curious Attachment
Having a world expert on Don Bosco living with you is
quite a gift. As precise and critical as Fr. Arthur Lenti
can be, I enjoy it very much when he speaks off the cuff
and shares his insights and opinions about the details of
Don Bosco’s life. He is not above raising question and
doubt while never losing respect or admiration for the
great saint and founder.
In a recent conversation, Fr. Arthur recounted the
propensity of Don Bosco to return again and again to
the story of his adolescent friendship with Luigi
Comollo. Fr. Arthur is not afraid to admit that this
relationship and its hold on Don Bosco’s adult life are a
bit of an anomaly. Why, really, was the adolescent
Bosco so taken by this boy whose personality and
temperament could not be more at odds to Bosco’s
own character? Bosco was certainly hungering for the
spiritual and his friend pointed him in that direction,
but the severity of this boy’s asceticism would not be a
tradition that Don Bosco translated into his own
pedagogy of spirituality. Instead, Don Bosco would
insist upon joyful, everyday—almost playful
holiness. We can surmise that the experience of
Comollo’s death somehow cut a groove into the
young Bosco at some intellectual and emotional
level. The experience of the relationship and its sad
ending has psychological significance, to be sure. One
has to wonder how connected was this loss to the other
traumatic losses of his childhood.
Yet, Don Bosco would return to the story of his friend
again and again. It was the first of his written
biographies and he reworked and edited many editions
for various audiences well into his old age. What can
we make of this?
2

1.3 Page 3

▲back to top
21
THTEHE LODROENM IPSUBMOSSCO
STUDY GUIDWEINNTOE.R32016
Preparation for Death and the Awareness of God’s
Attentive Presence
We know that Don Bosco’s Exercise for a
Happy Death was a key ingredient of his piety
and something he insisted should be part of the
Salesian tradition. During his time, there were
many harsh and tortured images of death
outside of faith or without the sacraments. This
fear hung over the cultural experience of God
for Don Bosco’s age. As far as we can tell,
much of Don Bosco’s youthful formation
wrung of such brooding rigorism and he was
able to navigate past those squalls of faith
because of key people in his own life.
Somehow, Don Bosco found the right point of
balance between watchfulness and fear,
between lively faith and dark piety. I would
like to delve a bit deeper into this dimension of
Don Bosco’s piety and for that, I turn to a study
I did regarding Don Bosco and the Last Things.
Comollo, Death, and Evil
I will refer much to Fr. Arthur’s critical analysis
of this trait.
Saint John Bosco’s next encounter with death
would come as a teenager in the seminary. His best
friend, Louis Comollo, became the model of sanctity
that John aspired to emulate. It is also obvious that
John became for Louis, the human balance this zealous
young man needed in his life. The descriptions of this
friendship are intimate and strong even though Saint
John Bosco never strays from the language of edifying
example and virtue. Reading between the lines,
however, it is not difficult to see the human dimension
to these affections especially when Louis dies an
untimely death. So distraught is John after the death of
his friend that he, himself, becomes quite ill. But there
is another interesting formative element in this
encounter with death. We see the development of a
conscious need to prepare well for death and to live
with meaning and purpose in every moment as if it
might be the last.
John struck a pact with his friend Louis that
whoever would die first would return to communicate
if and when they had reached salvation. John already
admired the piety and faith of his friend, but the
lessons of a life lived well and consciously prepared
for death would be seared into his memory with the
remarkable fulfillment of that pact. John related that
not long after the death of his friend, he found himself
inconsolable as he knelt praying at his own bedside.
Suddenly, with loud rumblings and shaking, which
awakened all the other seminarians, a light came to
hover over John and he heard his friend’s voice
announce three times, “Bosco, I am saved!”
This event pressed itself deeply on the mind
and heart of Saint John Bosco and it would develop in
him a lasting respect for the mystery of death and the
necessity to teach others how to live well and prepare
3

1.4 Page 4

▲back to top
43
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
for that moment.
The other deaths Saint John Bosco would
encounter would be no less important, but a detailed
investigation of these moments and their impact would
be, in themselves, the content of a thorough study. We
know from his own writings that there are at least four
more significant deaths to mention: the death of his
dear mother, Mama Margaret, and the deaths of three
students he would immortalize in writing: Dominic
Savio, Michael Magone, and Francis Besucco. These
are mentioned here to introduce the elements of death
in Saint John Bosco’s teaching, catechesis, and piety.
Writing about these significant persons in his life, long
after his mission is fully engaged, shows us the focus
of his teaching about death.
Teaching Others to Prepare for Death
Fr. Lenti gives a detailed description of Saint
John Bosco’s catechesis regarding death and the last
things. His survey is insightful and worth mentioning
to highlight various elements. Often, Saint John Bosco
would predict the deaths of others, especially boys at
his Oratory. He offered these predictions by way of
premonitions and dreams. He admitted that often times
the details were not clear until the events unfolded, but
he clung to the belief that it was beneficial for the boys
to know the reality and prepare for it. “He certainly
believed that confronting the youngsters with the
thought of death was both educational and spiritually
10
helpful.”
What is useful in this study, however, is
uncovering exactly what Saint John Bosco wanted to
teach his young charges with these warnings. The
biography Saint John Bosco penned for his friend
Comollo was primarily a catechetical tool to teach his
students the value of “the Last Things.” He developed
a pious tradition of conducting “an exercise for a happy
death” once every month for this purpose beginning in
1847. Fr. Lenti, in his review of Fr. Stella’s
examination of Saint John Bosco on the topic of death
predictions, points out that
10 Lenti, p. 693.
these practices were not meant to terrify the students.
They were intended to teach important lessons. Fr.
Lenti quotes Fr. Lemoyne from The Biographical
Memoirs of Saint John Bosco:
The Exercise for a Happy Death was
another powerful factor in his educational
system. When boys began boarding at the
Oratory, they made the exercise for a Happy
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
Death with the day pupils; later on he
scheduled it on the last Sunday of the month
for the former, and on the first Sunday for the
latter. To make it truly effective, he exhorted
them to put all their spiritual and temporal
things in order as though they were to appear
before God's tribunal on that day and to be
mindful that they could be suddenly called into
eternity. [...] The worldly-minded might think
that mentioning death to young boys would fill
their minds with gloomy thoughts, but that was
not so at all. On the contrary, it filled their
hearts with peace and joy. Spiritual unrest
11
comes from not being in God's grace.
An important part of the catechesis of Saint
John Bosco, then, centered on death and its
inevitability. However, the focus had its context and
points to important components in Saint John Bosco’s
ministry of education. The most obvious context was,
of course, the mortality rate in that part of the world in
the mid nineteenth century. In an age before anti-
biotics and treatments for common recurring illnesses,
sickness and disease often claimed many young lives.
The cholera epidemics of 1831 and 1854 were
experiences close to Saint John Bosco. In the first, he
had been a seminarian and witnessed the exodus of
many students under the direction of the protective
Jesuits. In the latter, the students of Saint John
Bosco’s Oratory would bravely assist the sick and
dying in the ravaged city of Turin, winning for the
boys and for Saint John Bosco the reputation of
holiness and courage. The possibility of a sudden and
unexpected death, at any age, then, was not far-fetched.
This had considerable bearing on the piety of the times.
There was a sense of urgency in living life.
Fidelity to one’s duty and faithfulness to God was not
something to postpone. At first glance, especially with
twenty-first century filters, this focus upon death may
seem morbid or suggest a catechesis reduced to scare-
tactics. And while fear was not an uncommon tool for
evangelization in Saint John Bosco’s era, the evidence
suggests that the predictions, the dreams, and the
practices of preparation for death had positive
consequences for the students in Saint John Bosco’s
care. Fr. Lenti’s survey of such death predictions and
the practice of the Exercise for a Happy Death comes
with a caution; he is well aware that fear by itself could
be psychologically damaging. He concludes this
survey, with appeals for caution, but concludes that
Saint John Bosco’s approach had to be much more than
fear to produce such peaceful and positive results in his
students. In fact, he mentions that many of the
4

1.5 Page 5

▲back to top
65
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
students lost their fear of death and strove to live in
readiness to meet God—considering the moment of
death to be a great and wonderful moment deserving of
one’s best preparation.
Perhaps the first most important component
revealed in this approach is an authentic love of God
based on a personal trust and the conscious
development of a deep relationship; such a relationship
created a longing for union with God. Certainly, the
flip side of this coin is a fear of hell and damnation,
and this was not a catechetical tactic left aside. But the
emphasis does not seem to be left in that dark place.
The student biographies mentioned earlier are Saint
John Bosco’s greatest testimony to the positive. With
this longing for union with God came abhorrence for
evil in all of its forms. This, too, has a flip side with a
focus upon the power of the devil prowling to devour a
soul. This particular focus upon the presence of evil
and its dangerous consequences often rises to the
surface of Saint John Bosco’s catechesis and not
infrequently without great drama and flare, but this will
be the next subject of comparison.
Death and Its Connections with Evil
Death predictions were not the only extra-
ordinary signs in Saint John Bosco’s life. He also had
vivid encounters with evil and seemed to be able to
read the presence of evil among the students. These
dimensions of Saint John Bosco will be analyzed more
carefully in the third section of this study, but for our
purposes here, a link needs to be made.
For Saint John Bosco, death was not a neutral
reality. He advocated a healthy fear of death as the
final consequence of sin and evil and the most dramatic
affirmation of its power. For Saint John Bosco,
physical death was always an impending possibility,
but it was spiritual death that preoccupied him more
than anything else. “Give me souls, take all else
away!” This was his life’s project as inspired by Saint
Francis de Sales. Saving and protecting the souls of his
students became the highest motivation for everything
he did. But his vision of evil did not confine itself to
moral ambiguity or mistaken choices; evil was a force
to avoid and to be prepared to combat with all one’s
resources. Details of his own resolutions at various
points in his own personal journey of spiritual growth
reveal this abhorrence for sin and evil and this
readiness to fight against them.
It is this abhorrence that is evident in the lives
of the young men Saint John Bosco examined in his
writings. He offered their examples as young people
whose love for God took primary place in all their
actions and goals. Like their mentor, they, too, made
5
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
resolutions to turn away from evil at every possible
encounter. In so doing, these young lads met death,
ready to meet God, victorious over sin and evil. They
were the models, not only of how to die, but also how
to live. They were models of combating evil in all of
its manifestations, internally and externally.
Evil in all its forms was to be avoided. For
Saint John Bosco, the devil could manifest itself in his
dreams and premonitions in terrifying detail. Yet, just
as terrifying was his presentation of moral decay. For
him, the external and the internal evils were all the
same.
One of us will not be able to make it
again. Who? It may be myself, or it may be one
of you! [...] I could tell you, but I won’t just
now. [...] When that happens, you will say, ‘I
never thought he would be the one to die!” [...]
I gave you something to think about. Really we
should meditate [on death] all the time. [...] We
have but one soul. [...] If we lose it, it would be
lost forever. [...] I know that boys [...] do wrong
with inconceivable light-mindedness and then
sleep for a long time with a horrible monster
that could tear them to pieces at any moment. Is
there anything to alert us to this danger? Yes,
the thought of death! I shall have to die one
day. [...] Will it be a slow death or a quick one?
Will it be this year, this month, today, tonight?
What will happen to my soul in that fatal hour?
12
If we lose it, it will be lost forever."

1.6 Page 6

▲back to top
12
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
From Accompanied to Accompanying
Don Bosco’s Biographies Pass on the Mission
A Movement of Accompaniment: the Sheep
Become Shepherds
Into the circle of his efforts to respond to the
cry of the young, Don Bosco would pull in
many resources from every sector of
Piedmontese society. From clergy to
government officials—even to the King
himself, Don Bosco called for
accompaniment of resources and concerned
action on behalf of these young people. His
plan took on more practical dimensions as
he envisioned preventive measures of
education for both social responsibility and
productivity as well as moral and religious
depth. These were two sides of the same
coin for him. While Don Bosco frequently
visited the young people in the poor places
where they lived and worked, another need
pressed itself upon him immediately and by
May of 1847, with his own mother
Margherita to assist him; he welcomed his
first orphaned and homeless boy. It is
interesting to note that Don Bosco quickly
found a “companion” for this lad by
opening the house to another orphan.
Soon, Don Bosco’s Oratory would be linked
to boarding students and housing the
homeless. This did not curtail him from
continuing to offer assistance to those who
did not stay with him. He continued to walk
the streets, to meet in the marketplace, to
visit the prisons, and to check on the
factories. These activities would never wane.
Instead, his focus on providing a whole
environment for the young in which to grow
into healthy citizens and committed
Christians took on new force.
He was always a collaborative man. He
launched many initiatives, but always with
others at his side. From Don Borel at the
Filippi fields, to Mamma Margherita at the
Pinardi House, to the Cooperators of future
days, Don Bosco reached out with the force of
an army of concerned individuals. Percolating
in his mind, early in the evolution of the first
Oratories of St. Francis de Sales and of the
Guardian Angels, was the intentional forming
of young people to take on his own tasks. This
happened at two significant levels. First, it was
a decisive part of the work of prevention in the
lives of his young people—forming
companions to keep each other from harm and
to increase in virtue. At another level, though,
was a new signpost growing clearer and
clearer as it approached: the formation of a
Salesian family of vowed members to carry on
the outreach he had begun. At both levels,
Don Bosco saw the fulfillment of sheep
becoming shepherds and felt the guidance of
the Shepherdess in the lead.
Human and Spiritual Accompaniment of Don
Bosco’s Students
We cross now from the accompaniment in the
life and faith journey of Don Bosco to the
accompaniment he offered to his own
students. Many of his students would become
his first Salesians. A look at these interactions
between Don Bosco and by referring to
personal testimonies of the young it is hoped
to reveal specific characteristics of the Salesian
spirituality of accompaniment and its earliest
applications. In such details are found
intentional strategies and tactics of Don Bosco
for reaching the heart of a young person and
offer a passage to find fulfilment and holiness.
6

1.7 Page 7

▲back to top
43
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
The Biographies of Three Students
of the Oratory at Valdocco: Living
Hermeneutics
Normative to a study of Don Bosco’s
pedagogy and spirituality are the
biographies he penned for three of his
students to be preserved as models for
imitation offered to all of his students
present and future. In reality, there are four
specific biographies, but the life of Comollo
has been mentioned and is distinguished
from the student biographies as a memoir of
a seminary companion of Don Bosco.
There are, of course, other students
mentioned in Don Bosco’s writings, but no
others are written with such detail and with
such clear intent.
Aldo Giraudo, Salesian scholar and
professor at the Università Ponificia
Salesiana in Rome, has offered a structure
for evaluating the encounters of these
particular students as recorded by Don
Bosco. This structure is helpful for
deciphering these biographies for what is
common in Don Bosco’s approach with
these students and what distinguishes one
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
from the other. Such analysis enables themes
and styles to surface in the effort for a
spirituality of accompaniment to emerge.
Giraudo offers three levels of narration for
organizing the biographies1. The first levels
make use of historical details filtered through
the “hagiographical aspects of the virtues
concerned.” The next level reveals the “hidden
plot” of Don Bosco giving us a window into
what is important for Don Bosco; this permits
us a view of his ideas of good behaviour and
holiness, his manner of relating to the
students, and his deepest convictions. The
third level or organization2 demonstrates the
identical narrative sequence Don Bosco
followed in each biography, namely:
The early life
The meeting with Don Bosco
Life at Valdocco
Crisis, decision and transition
The spiritual program
Sickness and death
Epilogue
The dusting of these biographies for the
fingerprints of a spirituality of accompaniment
will not include detailed historical information
in the life of the subject (though some
contextual information is always necessary)
nor attempt a contextual analysis of Valdocco.
However, the investigation pointedly focuses
on the meeting with Don Bosco and what is
revealed about his personal convictions. The
process of “winning their hearts” will be
touched upon with a more thorough
examination of this experience at a later point
in this work. With these parts of the narrative
sequence isolated, it is hoped to reveal the
spiritual program inside of a framework of
accompaniment.
Giraudo suggests that there is often
opposition between the argumentative
discourse and the narrative discourse in a
narration, but he supports a union of purpose
between these two dimensions. The
7

1.8 Page 8

▲back to top
65
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
interaction between the lived situation and
its recounting reveals something important.
In other words, the time at which an
account of a past encounter is made reveals
something in that encounter which serves as
a unique form of communication. For Don
Bosco “in the perspective of the Oratory the
story intends to transmit something, to
disclose a pastoral model and an
educational method, a spirit and
spirituality…”3 He suggests a link between
the story and Don Bosco’s reason for telling
it. The communication was never simply the
recounting of facts, but, in reality, a
hermeneutic intended to evoke “what it
reveals”3 in its listeners. Giraudo borrows an
idea from Paul Ricoeur explaining that Don
Bosco always included in the narrative a
moment of challenge, something that
needed resolution, in order to provoke a
question that demanded a personal response
inside of his listener/reader.5 This
provocation has the special quality to
survive beyond the moment of the
recounting and sets up a dialogue with all
listeners/readers in the future, regardless of
their own situations.
Don Bosco wanted to save souls. He
wanted these stories to provoke a longing for
holiness in the hearts of his listeners and
make the encounters their own. We turn
briefly to the narratives of these biographies
to discover what they reveal about a
spirituality of accompaniment.
Dominic Meets the Tailor: Accompaniment
and Dominic Savio
The most famous, and perhaps the most
studied, among the student biographies are
Don Bosco’s narration of the life of
Dominic Savio. Don Bosco begins with
details from Dominic’s home-life. What is
important in these details is not the
historical chronology so much as the
foundations laid for building a life of
holiness. Inside of the narration is the
exposition of Dominic’s hunger for God and
the paths the boy took in pursuit of spiritual
8
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
nourishment. Giraudo contextualizes the
telling of these details within a certain
religious and psychological profile of this
young man: an anxiety for eternal salvation,
anguish over the possibility of damnation,
propensity for emotional religiosity, the
dramatic perception of sin, and the view of
God as both merciful Father and fearful judge.
He demonstrated an early love and devotion
for the Mother of God, an intense mystical
awareness of the Eucharist, a desire, and
delight for the vocation of the priesthood, a
longing to study, and a heroic level of self-
donation. These are the historical and
anthropological character traits Giraudo
identifies as those considered by Don Bosco
for an intentional interpretation of the boy’s
life.6
Such longings, sentiments, devotions, and
fears would not have been unfamiliar to Don
Bosco’s students at any of the points in which
the narrative was offered. They point up the
character of life and culture for that time and
region. Don Bosco insisted here, as in other
writings, the necessity of religion for a sound
and complete education. It is enough to recall
that Don Bosco proposed a style of education
at a time of great anti-clerical sentiment
suspicious of
faith and the
influences of
religion.
Giraudo
points out
that Don
Bosco’s
response to
this situation
is evident in
the saint’s
repeated
association
of educators with shepherds. In this insistence,
Don Bosco highlights the role of one who
accompanies; an educator concerned more for
the whole child than merely his academic
formation. In addition, the power of that
illustration is made in describing the
interaction that occurs between Don Bosco
and Dominic.

1.9 Page 9

▲back to top
78
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
Dominic’s hunger for holiness, nurtured by
his family, noticed and fostered by his
pastor, and finally brought to the attention
of Don Bosco, was in need of direction and
formation. In the narration, the central
theme is depicted in Dominic’s meeting
with Don Bosco at the saint’s office. There,
Dominic sees Don Bosco’s life motto: Da
mihi animas, caetera tolle. Dominic asks for an
explanation, is moved, and takes the
occasion, eventually, to ask Don Bosco to
be his special guide. The boy offers himself
as a willing piece of cloth to be tailored in
the skillful hands of Don Bosco. Here we
find the meeting of two models: the young
saint and the ideal educator. This begins a
narrative with clear intent to reveal “a book
of spirituality and narrative pedagogy.”6
Don Bosco’s response to this request sets
down a spiritual itinerary for Dominic to
follow and outlines a very particular
spirituality. He begins by telling Dominic to
continually lift his heart and thoughts to
God in prayer. In the next moment, Don
Bosco cautions Dominic that two tools are
necessary for the heart to remain attached to
God. The first is mortification and the
second is virtue. By mortification, innocence
is preserved and by living virtuously, the
love of God is known and demonstrated to
others. Immediately a link is forged between
personal piety and communal responsibility.
This will become the template for a spiritual
life. All the other tools are means for
fostering these gifts of innocence and
virtuous living. The presentation of this
encounter puts the reader in the meeting and
raises the same challenge to maintain
innocence and live exemplary lives of virtue.
In fact, as Don Bosco concludes the
narrative of Dominic, he again addresses the
reader and explicitly reveals what is the
heart of his motive: to invite the reader to
“pass from the plan of the narration to the
religious message, from the contemplation
of the ‘pleasing, virtuous, and innocent’ life
of Dominic to personal commitment, from
admiration to imitation.”8
Stella’s analysis of the same material
uncovers what he calls a typical post-tridentine
9
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
hagiography at the center of the narration.9
These include: the spirit of prayer, the
devotions to the Eucharist and to Mary, the
practice of charity toward others, and
collective religious attitudes of associations
and sodalities. Don Bosco’s contribution to
these appears in the homilies he gave on
holiness and which move Dominic Savio’s
heart. This preaching on the vocation of
holiness was followed by one on the zeal for
souls and this seems to lead in the narrative to
Dominic’s decision to form the Company of
Mary Immaculate. Here again, the process
moves from personal piety to communal
responsibility—indispensable for
understanding this particular spirituality.
In every biography, Don Bosco emphasizes
the necessity of frequent confession and a
consistent confessor. To Dominic, he
recommends these as indispensable for
holiness. He enshrines the virtues of doing
one’s duties to their fullest and with a cheerful
disposition. Dominic becomes the prime
example of choosing good companions and
correcting those who stray from the fold
through unhealthy relationships. His
devotions for the Eucharist and to Mary are
highlighted as extra-ordinary and spill over
into the supernatural. The mention of the
supernatural, however, is presented by Don
Bosco not as the end in itself, but as a further
confirmation that a young person could
authentically give witness to the highest
expressions of faith and the most profound
experiences of God.
In the study of Giraudo, he enumerates
observable steps in the spiritual sequence
proposed by Don Bosco in these narratives.
The means to holiness, then, are:
Piety
Fulfillment of duties/studies
Cheerfulness
Mortification
Apostolate
Charitable service
Practice of virtues

1.10 Page 10

▲back to top
90
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
Tending toward holiness
These would remain simply ideals if they
were not presented as lived realities in the
lives of Dominic and the other students. He
presents Dominic as a model of attainable
and visible holiness. His biography is not an
“ideological deformation of the originating
historical event” but a participation and
mediation of the reality of spiritual life,
bringing closer the experience of Christ and
provoking in them a dramatic decision.10
Taking the challenge of seeing in the
holiness of the saints a living hermeneutic,
Dominic Savio is Don Bosco’s prime
example of living holiness.
“He has a good heart”: Accompaniment
and Michele Magone
The starting point of Michele Magone is
obviously a radical departure from the
foundations in the life of Dominic Savio. So
different, in fact, that Magone’s starting
point appears as an intentional device of
Don Bosco. We will see in the treatment of
Francesco Besucco, that it is both lives taken
together which inspires this third boy to
become a saint.
Michelle’s plight shared similarities to Don
Bosco’s story: the loss of his father, a
hardworking mother, and the lack of means
to rise above this lived situation and get an
education. Don Bosco’s meeting with the
boy is nothing like Dominic’s. In Dominic’s
case, the eagerness to meet with Don Bosco
and the strong desire for holiness propelled
him to Don Bosco. In Michele’s case, Don
Bosco runs into “the General in charge of
the game”10 at the train station and slowly
wins the boy’s trust. The starting points are
vastly different, but the end points are
strikingly similar. Whereas Dominic’s heart
seemed to be formed by his parents, his
pastor, and an intuited love for God,
Michele’s heart seems trapped inside of an
impatient and intelligent lad not given to
study or to catechism. Every attempt to
harness this energy is met with frustration
and disappointment. Despite this, Michele’s
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
pastor sees a deep goodness in the boy’s heart.
This is the essential condition for holiness.
Don Bosco’s intention seems clear in this
detail. He accepts the recommendation of the
boy for the Oratory because the pastor insists
the boy “has a good heart.”
Is there a lack of accompaniment in the boy’s
life, then? The accompaniment afforded
Dominic Savio is certainly evident and comes
from every angle. However, like Mamma
Margherita, Magone’s mother did the best she
could having to go away often to find work.
Her intentions were good. Her means were
limited. Don Bosco saw the boy’s goodness in
his train station and marketplace meetings, but
he awaited the same recognition in the pastor.
This subtle detail is telling. Don Bosco does
not encourage accompaniment. He insists
upon it. Without the presence of the
interested pastor, one wonders if Don Bosco
would have ever made the invitation to
Magone to come to the Oratory. What was
assured in the life of young Dominic was not
as evident for Michele.
As with Dominic, Don Bosco would enlist
Magone into a life of spiritual hunger and the
desire to become a saint. This met Magone
from a different path than that of Dominic.
Don Bosco’s first level of appeal was for
Magone’s leadership and not explicitly his
religiosity or devotion. It seems that
immersed in the spiritual environment of his
peers, Magone’s leadership was not enough to
bring the boy satisfaction. What was missing
was not immediately clear to Magone and it
seems Don Bosco allowed the question to
deepen in the boy’s heart until Magone,
himself, came to the realization of his own
hunger.
One has to imagine many groups of boys from
all manner of varied backgrounds sitting and
listening to Don Bosco’s stories finding
themselves attracted in one way or other to
one or the other model of holiness. How
many knew their thirst for holiness like
Dominic? How many were innocently
unaware until they spent sufficient time in the
Oratory with Don Bosco and those caught by
his invitation?
Let us highlight Don Bosco’s intuition to find
10

2 Pages 11-20

▲back to top

2.1 Page 11

▲back to top
12
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
the potential for Magone to become not only
a leader but also a companion to his peers.
How interesting is the intuition!
Accompaniment, then, is the capacity to
lead, the ability to invite, the inspiration to
transform, and the trust to let God’s Spirit
do the work. Dominic had this ability.
Magone did as well. In the best and most
apostolic sense, Don Bosco seemed to be
covering all of his bases! He found willing
hearts with different faces.
The key to Magone’s story is the basic
goodness in the boy. Every means
suggested to Dominic became the passion of
Magone after he realized that his life was
empty so long as he was incapable of the
same sense of prayer and meaning. Soon,
confession and a regular confessor became
unquestionable for Magone. He, too, gave
himself to the Eucharist and the Mother of
God. Yet, at first, these devotions and
practices held no appeal to him. This is
significant because the narration testifies to
a heart not only attracted to Don Bosco, but
one in which Don Bosco highlighted its
goodness and invited the boy to deeper
transformation. The raw materials were
present. Holiness was possible.
The Gift of Diligence: Accompaniment and
Francesco Besucco
Francesco Besucco is Don Bosco’s synthesis
and spirituality put on full display. Here
was a lad from poor means, loved by a large
“harmonious” family, drawn like Savio
from his earliest memories to prayer and
devotion. Here was a boy whose mother,
like Mamma Margherita, wanted holiness
for her son above all other gifts. Francesco
was a child whose goodness touched the
heart of his pastor and whose hunger for
knowledge of God and heavenly things was
extraordinary.
Francesco had read the lives of both Savio
and Magone and connected strongly with
their experiences. Here was a member of
Don Bosco’s audience tuning into the
frequencies intentionally signalled by Don
Bosco in these writings.
11
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
The link between the three boys seems to be
the important support they received from their
pastors. This key person of accompaniment
saw each one with the greatest of potential and
each contacted Don Bosco to help foster this
capacity within them.
In this particular biography, Don Bosco
explicitly states that Francesco’s heart had
become possessed by God.
When the love of God takes possession of a heart,
nothing in this world and no suffering distress it; on
the other hand every affliction in this life is a source
of consolation.12
It was this that gave Don Bosco fertile ground
to shape a soul.
His avenue of
approach
respected the
gift of
Francesco. This
was not an
accompaniment
of coercion, but
invitation.
Discovering his
love of studies
and his great diligence, Don Bosco made this
the sure roadmap for Besucco’s path to
holiness. Don Bosco saw his responsibility to
be an important one in this act of
accompaniment. Daniel O’ Leary captures
well the vocation of accompaniment as he
writes:
Maybe, as well as being called to save and convert
people into membership of the church, we are first
called to the primary task of liberating people into the
fullness of their own already graced humanity, into
revealing to people the blessedness of their very
being, of their capacity for living the abundant life in
the here and the now.13
In fact, Don Bosco even admitted some
reservations that Besucco’s thirst for holiness
was a bit misguided in his excessive attempts
for physical suffering and mortification. Don
Bosco will go so far as to suggest that this area
seemed an obstacle and weakness in Besucco
that may have contributed to his untimely
death. That being said, there is an interesting

2.2 Page 12

▲back to top
34
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
detail that surfaces in this admission. Don
Bosco felt himself standing at the door of a
mystery. He had often felt this way in the
presence of Savio, given to ecstasies and
premonitions. He had the same feelings as
he watched the transformation of Magone
into a champion of good and frequent
confession. Now the feelings returned as
Besucco’s sudden illness and death filled
Don Bosco with awe. He suggested:
God saw the great love that this little heart had for
Him and to prevent the evil of this world from
ruining him, He decided to call him to Himself; he
allowed an inordinate love of penance to a certain
extent to be responsible for it.14
We see in this Don Bosco’s clarity regarding
his own role in the lives of the students. He
was to accompany and guide, but God had
the last word. The role of the guide is to lead
the youth to awareness of God’s goodness
already present and at work in the soul. His
job is one of invitation, not creation--of
encouragement, not coercion. This
awareness did not lessen Don Bosco’s
passion for saving souls; it simply respected
the roles of those concerned and placed all
the efforts into the hands of God.
Common Themes of Accompaniment from
Comollo to Besucco
There has been no attempt to include the
biography of Luigi Comollo here or the
disappointing story of a lost invitation in a
student named Valentino. There are,
however, common themes from all of these
stories. Don Bosco’s narrative of the life of
his seminary companion returns us again to
the theme of accompaniment in his own life.
It was the depth of his friend that invited the
young Giovanni into deeper awareness and
the thirst for an interior life. Certainly, these
had been implanted in Don Bosco from the
start and we have seen influential persons
and some of the events that molded his
desire for holiness. However, the story of
Comollo highlights a detail that runs
throughout every narration, even those
ending in apparent disappointment. Every
narration presents a moment of crisis. The
12
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
crisis is very different from one protagonist to
another, but a decision is provoked in every
instance. Again, we call to mind the notion of
the saints as true testimonies bringing the
Incarnation of Christ closer and demanding a
choice, in the views of Von Balthasar.
Often times the crises are not neatly packaged
in one event or person but sprout in the garden
of particular seasons of life as a cumulative
effect or a moment of reckoning. In some
cases, though, they are dramatic turning
points. For Giovanni Bosco, the meeting with
Comollo seems to have been one that forever
changed him.
Stella notices that the original text was
structured chronologically and did not devote
large portions to the development of some
virtue. This separates this narrative from
those of Savio, Magone, and Besucco.
Indeed, what is common to all of them is the
dearth of biographical detail and the anecdotal
method with the goal of edifying and inspiring
the reader.15 One obvious additional device
employed in this early writing is the
comparisons offered between Comollo and
Saint Aloysius Gonzaga.
In Comollo’s biography arise sayings and
maxims that would be found throughout Don
Bosco’s works, repeated in his Companion to
Youth, and in other publications such as the
biographies mentioned in this study. Yet it is
curious that a decisively different quality of
spirituality asserted itself in Comollo that
would not survive in the later works: an
excessive personal piety. Comollo wanted to
withdraw from life completely. While this
translates in Don Bosco’s later writings as a
detachment from the world and its priorities, it
never becomes an obsessive dualism finding
evil in every created thing. Fortunately, for
Don Bosco’s spirituality of accompaniment,
there is a marked celebration of life and
creation calling for participation rather than
withdrawal. Such spirituality involves others
rather than judges them. It rejoices in
communal participation and mediation rather
than self-preoccupation.
It is fortunate for the legacy of Don Bosco that
in him we receive a more mature view of God
as judge. Certainly, Don Bosco wove images

2.3 Page 13

▲back to top
56
THTEHEDLOONREBMOSIPCSOUMSTS UDY GUIDE NO. 3
DECWEIMNTBEERR22001611
that were frightening and moved many a
young heart to steer clear of hell, but for
Comollo, the vision of his own
condemnation and fear of a wrathful God
became excessive. Might we make the link
between the moment of hope that followed
upon the great fear of Saint Francis de Sales
and conclude that Don Bosco clung to this
hope and made it
his own? The
devotion to Saint
Francis de Sales,
so much a part of
Don Bosco and
his region, figures
richly in Don
Bosco’s history of
founding the
Oratories and
establishing a
Salesian Family.
Familiar to Don
Bosco and his
contemporaries
would be the tale of the young lawyer and
student of theology at the Sorbonne in Paris
finding himself on the verge of despair.
Having lived and breathed a loving and
natural relationship with God in his home,
the young scholar was repeatedly struck by
the harsh soteriology of his Dominican and
Franciscan professors. Salvation was
reserved for the few. Logically, Francis’ bid
for salvation would be challenged to the
core. This was the crisis, which, through
prayer and divine intervention, would
fashion the great Doctor of God’s love.
Don Bosco’s patron had dedicated himself
to combat these heretical and dark views of
a loving God and rob the soul of God’s
closeness and availability. Don Bosco
would join in this battle with passion.
Saving souls, not threatening them, not
terrifying them into submission, was his
lifelong mission and he would speak the
language of a Good Shepherd, the language
of reasonable, loving kindness and faith.
Perhaps the most important detail to
underline in the narration of Comollo is his
friendship with Giovanni and Giovanni
with him. Here is a complementary model. A
spirituality of accompaniment begins with a
seed planted in an open heart and proceeds
through its stages of growth with various
positive aids to that growth, including helpful
persons and events. The journey of the
budding spirituality necessarily depends on the
intentions of others for designed and planned
growth and formation, for nurturance by word
and example. The greatest danger to the
forming life is exposure to dangerous elements
and the evil intentions of others. The
framework of this spirituality is a shared
journey to fruition. It is spirituality fiercely
guarded by those who see the potential of
holiness in another and who actively protects,
guides, and nurtures the journey to fullness.
The first line of defense is always at the peer
level. This was the insight culled from his
experience of Comollo. This is the
importance of “good companions” becoming
the guardians and protectors of the spiritual
journey Don Bosco would offer to the young.
These companions acknowledge the goodness
of God already at work in life and participate
in the invitation to act as co-creators with a
loving God.
Endnotes
1 Cf. Aldo GIRAUDO, Narrazione e
formazione dei gionvani, livelli di lettura e chiavi
interpretative di alcuni opera narrative di don
Bosco, Dispense ad uso degli studenti, Roma, UPS,
2007,
2 Cf. GIRAUDO, Narrazione e formazione
dei giovani,
3 Cf. GIRAUDO, Narrazione e formazione
dei giovani, 4. This is my translation of the text: il
racconto di sé in prospettiva oratoriana vuol dire,
trasmettere qualcosa, svelare un modello pastorale e
un metodo educativo, uno spirito e una
spiritualità…, un racconto memorialistico che, nel
suo stesso impianto narrativo, si rivela
profondamente argomentativo, esprimendo la sua
argomentazione attraverso lo strumento di una
narrazione.
Così vorremmo che attraverso il corso
traspaia uno stretto legame tra il racconto di Don
Bosco e la sua argomentazione, legame troppo
13

2.4 Page 14

▲back to top
87
THE LOREM IPSUMS
WINTER 2016
spesso sconosciuto agli approcci tradizionali, ma anche
a quelli di tipo semiotico.
4 Cf. GIRAUDO, Narrazione e formazione dei
giovani, 4.
5 Cf. GIRAUDO, Narrazione e formazione dei
giovani, 5.
6 Cf: A. GIRAUDO (cur.), Domenico Savio
raccontato da don Bosco. Riflessioni sulla “Vita.” Atti
del Simposio. Università Pontificia Salesiana, Roma, 8
maggio 2004. LAS, Roma, 2005, 42-60.
7 Cf. GIRAUDO, Domenico Savio raccontato
da don Bosco, 46.
8 Cf. GIRAUDO, Domenico Savio raccontato
da don Bosco, 48 (my translation).
9 Cf. STELLA, Don Bosco nella storia della
religiosità cattolica, vol. II: Mentalità religiosa e
spiritualità, Roma, LAS, 21981, 218-225
10 Cf. Larry CHAPP, Revelation in Edward T.
OAKES and David MOSES (Eds.),The Cambridge
Companion to Hans Urs Von Balthasar, Cambridge,
Cambridge University Press, 22006,23.
11 Cf. John BOSCO, Biographical sketch of
Michael Magone, young pupil at the Oratory of St
Francis de Sales, (translation by Aldo Giraudo),
Torino, Tipografia dell’Oratorio di S. Francesco di
Sales 21866, 3.
12 John BOSCO: The young shepherd of the
Alps, or the life of the young Francis Besucco of
Argentera, (translation by Also Giraudo) Torino,
Tipografia dell’Oratorio di S. Francesco di Sales
21878.
13 Daniel O’LEARY, New Hearts, New
Models, Dublin, The Columba Press, 1997, 18.
14 BOSCO: The young shepherd of the Alps,
21866.
14

2.5 Page 15

▲back to top
GeTttHinEg tLoOKRnEoMw DIPoSnUBMosSco Study Guide
DecWemINbTerE2R0121016
Suggestions for Use of this Guide...
During the Advent Season...
Share the familiar stories of
Christmases past with each other.
While you are remembering past
Christmas celebrations, recall a story
or two of a young person who moved
you personally by the example of
that person’s life.
Invite local youth to an Advent
Service and invite them to share the
same stories in their lives.
The Cooperators of the Province have a
wonderful opportunity for organizing mission
trips to the poor for the young people in their
neighborhoods and parishes.
Gather a local group of teens and
young adults to pick a service project
After the day of service, share a meal
and ask the young people to imagine
what Don Bosco did in the cold
winters of Turin. How did he meet
the needs of the youth during those
cold months?
Advent and Christmas are rich
opportunities to connect meaningfully
with young people. Become involved in
a service project or outreach to the poor
with a group of young people.
Invite the young people to share
their experiences of ministry in
this season by writing an article
or by setting up shared
experiences of prayer and
celebration
Invite the young to prepare an
Advent Service using their
culture to retell the story of
Christmas
15
In this month of exams, deadlines, traffic,
and lines at the retail shops, take a step
back to breathe and to pray.
Gather with your colleagues for an
evening of reflection followed by a shared
meal. Don’t give in to the temptation to
leap over Advent for a Christmas Party.
Instead, celebrate the story of our longing
for a Savior. After prayer and sharing,
over a potluck meal, invite one another to
share stories of faith and meaning.
Explore what it means for us today to
long for our Savior and what it means to
bear Christ into the world.

2.6 Page 16

▲back to top
THE DON BOSCO STUDY GUIDE NO. 3
THE LOREM IPSUMS
DECEMBER 2011
WINTER 2016
Merry Christmas!
The snowcaps of the Alps form a backdrop to a
winter portrait of Turin, Italy. Whether you are
dreaming of a White Christmas or a Golden
Winter Tan, we wish you all the best for the
great solemnity of Christmas. May the coming
year bring you closer to the Savior and closer to
the precious roots we find in Don Bosco!
Institute of Salesian Spirituality
1831 Arch Street]
Berkeley, CA 94709
Share your questions for Fr. Arthur...
Please send your questions regarding the History of Don
Bosco and his place in History to Fr. Arthur. Send these to
DonBoscoHallCA@gmail.com
Guidelines for Deeper Study...
From the Critical Works of Fr. Arthur
Lenti peruse the following treatments of
the material included in this Study Guide
Read Chapter 11, “John Bosco at
the Public Secondary School of
Chieri,” in Don Bosco History and
Spirit volume 1, pp. 245-289.
Pay particular attention to those
details of the adolescent Bosco
which begin on p.259 and read
through 267 with the details of “the
Happiness Club,” Jonah, and Louis
Comollo.
Continue reading into chapter 12,
“John Bosco’s Vocational Crisis
and Discernment at Chieri (1834-
1835) pp. 291-309. Note the
interesting critical corrections made
to the MO in these pages.
From the Memoirs of the Oratory of St. Francis de
Sales, by St. John Bosco, read the following
sections:
Read Chapters 8-16, pp.53-74. These
chapters carry to the end of Part I of the
MO.
Note Chapter 16 in which Don Bosco
describes his vocational crisis and
discernment.
Compare these details to those recorded
by Lemoyne and the critical corrections
regarding the recurring vocational dream
and Don Bosco’s experience of
discernment.

2.7 Page 17

▲back to top
INSTITUTE OF SALESIAN SPIRITUALITY
Exploring
Don Bosco
A Three Night Study and Reflection Series
7:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Evening One
Evening Two
Evening Three
Don Bosco
Post-modern
The Young
in His Time
Don Bosco?
Adult Bosco
In Northern California: DON BOSCO HALL BERKELEY
Monday January 9, 2012
Tuesday January 10, 2012 Wednesday January 11, 2012
In Southern California: SALESIAN RESIDENCE LOS ANGELES
Tuesday January 17, 2012 Wednesday January 18, 2012 Thursday January 19, 2012
This evening explores Don
Bosco’s historical and
cultural settings which
shaped his vision and
mission. Understanding
those influences help us to
“begin afresh” from his
perspective to enable our
times to intersect with
his.
Can the historical figure of Don
Bosco offer insight for our own
time and place situated within a
post-modern crisis of meaning?
What clues has this saint left us
for navigating our way back to
the “meta-story” of the Gospel?
Examining the young adult
Giovanni Bosco, on his way to
his mission and taking the first
steps in his dreams, offers us a
rich model of discernment and
faith. Looking at his
friendships, his seeking out
mentors and spiritual guides,
and his own ascetic choices
offers today’s young adult a
roadmap for mission and an
itinerary for everyday holiness.
There is no fee for this series.

2.8 Page 18

▲back to top
INSTITUTE FOR SALESIAN SPIRITUALITY PRESENTS...
A Special Retreat on Don Bosco
The Don Bosco Retreats are offered for young adults and adults of the
Salesian Family: members of Salesian parishes, youth centers, school
faculties and staff, adult past pupils, and collaborators in the Salesian
Mission. This weekend experience will offer reflection, discussion, and
prayer around the life of Don Bosco, his place in history, and his
impact on our lives and ministries today
“Don Bosco In History”
January 6-8, 2012
Don Bosco Hall
Berkeley
January 20-22, 2012
Salesian Residence
Los Angeles
The retreat begins at 7:00 PM on Friday evening and
concludes at lunch on Sunday.
Cost for materials, meals and lodging for 3 days inclusive, $60.00
Retreat Registration
Mail registration to Don Bosco Hall 1831 Arch Street, Berkeley, CA 94709 or Fax to (510) 704-1925
Name: __________________________________________ Email: ___________________________
Address: ___________________________________________________________________________
Check which retreat you would like to attend.
January 6-8 Berkeley
January 20-22, Los Angeles
Checks payable to Salesians of Don Bosco. Space is limited. Register by December 29, 2011.